Online Therapy in English
Therapy Apps vs. a Private Therapist: An Honest Comparison
The subscription platforms put therapy in everyone's feed, and a private therapist costs more per hour. The real differences sit underneath the pricing, in the matching, the incentives, and what happened to the data. Laid out plainly, including where the apps genuinely win.
What the platforms actually are
BetterHelp, Talkspace, and their competitors are marketplaces: they recruit licensed therapists at scale, recruit clients through enormous ad budgets, match the two by algorithm and questionnaire, and bill the client a subscription, typically charged monthly at a rate that works out to several hundred dollars for a bundle of weekly video sessions plus messaging. The model has real virtues. It collapses the search problem to a signup form. It reaches people in therapy deserts. It prices below most private practice in expensive markets. And it normalized online therapy for millions of people who would never have called a private office. Those are genuine achievements and it would be dishonest to wave them away.
The mechanics worth understanding before you subscribe
The trade-offs live in the structure. Matching is fast because it is shallow: a questionnaire and an algorithm assign you a counselor with capacity, and while you can switch, each switch restarts the relationship that does the actual clinical work. Therapist turnover on the platforms is significant, because platform pay rates run well below private-practice rates and reward volume, which also shapes session length and the temptation of asynchronous messaging as a substitute for the harder, realer hour. The subscription itself changes the frame: you are a recurring revenue unit in a retention funnel, and the product being optimized is engagement, which is related to, but not the same thing as, getting better. None of the individual therapists are villains in this; many are skilled people using the platforms as flexible income. The incentives are simply what they are.
The privacy record, factually
One part of this comparison is not a matter of framing. In March 2023 the US Federal Trade Commission announced an enforcement action against BetterHelp, alleging that between 2013 and 2020 the company shared the email addresses, IP addresses, and health questionnaire answers of users with Facebook, Snapchat, Criteo, and Pinterest for advertising purposes, after promising users that health information would stay private. BetterHelp agreed to a consent order that included 7.8 million dollars for consumer refunds and a ban on sharing health data for advertising; it did not admit wrongdoing. The order is public on the FTC's site. Whatever one concludes about the platforms today, the episode established something structural: when therapy is delivered by an ad-funded growth company, your intake answers are corporate data, governed by policies that can fail. A private therapist holds your material under a clinical frame; there is no growth team with access to it, because there is no growth team.
Want to talk about this?
I work with expats all over the world, in English, online.
A brief conversation to see if this feels like the right fit for you. Not therapy.
What a private therapist is, in this comparison
Private online therapy inverts most of the structure. You choose one specific person deliberately, vet their actual training, and pay them directly per session, no subscription, no platform percentage, no engagement funnel. The relationship is the product, it deepens instead of resetting, and the therapist's only incentive is the work going well enough that you keep choosing it. The honest costs: the search takes real effort (I wrote a full guide to running that search abroad), the per-session price is usually higher than the platform's per-session math, and there is no app holding your hand between sessions. For depth work, for anything characterological, for couples, and for anyone whose privacy stakes are professional rather than theoretical, the private structure is simply built for the job in a way a marketplace is not.
When the apps are the right call
A fair comparison ends by conceding real territory. If cost is the binding constraint, a platform subscription may be the difference between some support and none. If you are in a genuine therapy desert and want a licensed human this week, the apps deliver exactly that. If what you need is short-term, supportive, and structured, a platform counselor can do it well. And for a first-ever taste of therapy, low commitment has value. The honest framing is tiers, not enemies: the platforms solved access; private practice solves depth. Knowing which problem you actually have is most of the decision, and a serious private therapist will tell you in a first call if the cheaper tier is genuinely all you need. I do, regularly, and the call costs nothing.
I write about this stuff.
Not tips. Not advice. Just honest writing about what it feels like to live far from home. If you want the next one, leave your email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Just essays.