It starts with an intrusive thought you never asked for. It might be violent, sexual, or blasphemous, or a sudden image of something awful happening. You push it away, and it returns. You argue with it and then check whether it is still there. Soon the worry is about you: What if I want this? What if I could do it? You keep it to yourself, afraid someone will hear the thought and judge you by it.
The thought does not, by itself, mean you want to act on it. If it horrifies you, that matters. It is evidence that the thought is unwelcome, not proof of a wish. People who act on harmful impulses do not typically spend their days in agony over having those impulses. Still, the fear can survive every answer you give it. You cannot reason your way to certainty when each answer leads to one more question.
What the research shows
Intrusive thoughts are common, even when their content is frightening. Research on unwanted thoughts goes back to the late 1970s. A 2014 study looked at nearly 800 students in 13 countries. More than nine in ten reported at least one intrusive thought in the past three months. In earlier work, Rachman and de Silva found that ordinary obsessions were common and resembled the ones people with OCD report in form and content. They can involve harming someone you love, an unwanted sexual image, a sudden catastrophe, or an impulse to do something terrible in public. The content alone does not separate people who struggle from those who do not.
The difference is what happens next. For most people, an intrusive thought arrives, gets noticed, and passes. When you struggle with intrusive thoughts, it gets caught instead. Say an intrusive thought shows up while you wait for a train: What if I push someone? You may treat it as a clue to who you are, even though you never chose it. The same thing can happen with an unwanted sexual image. You ask what it means, look for a sign that you meant it, and try to push it out. The fear leads to checking and more suppression. But suppression can backfire. A 2020 review brought together 31 studies in which people were told not to think about something. Once they stopped trying, the thought tended to return more often than in groups that had not tried to suppress it. Earlier meta-analyses had found the same rebound effect.
This is the trap at the heart of intrusive thoughts. The thing you are doing to make them go away is the thing that is keeping them here.
Why the standard advice has limits
Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP), usually offered as part of CBT, is a well-supported treatment for intrusive thoughts. It asks you to face a feared thought without the checking, rituals, or avoidance that usually follow. Over time, the distress can lessen. ERP has strong evidence, helps many people, and is worth trying if you have access to a good therapist who offers it.
My work asks something else as well. Why does a certain thought strike you as unbearable? Why does it seem to say so much about who you are? ERP helps with the way you respond to a thought. I want to understand the pattern that made you see parts of your own mind as dangerous in the first place.
In my clinical view, many struggles with intrusive thoughts have less to do with OCD in a technical sense than with how you learned to treat your own inner life. You may have grown up afraid of anger, desire, or needing too much. Now an unwanted thought lands on the very feeling you have worked hard to keep out of sight. The fear can feel like proof that the thought matters.
Fifteen minutes is enough to know if this fits.
Request a free 15-min consultationWhat is going on
Say the intrusive thought that scares you most is violent. One pattern I see is fear of anger itself. If you have spent years making sure you never snap, disappoint anyone, or take up too much room, even a passing thought of hurting someone sets off an alarm. The thought "I could hurt someone" is terrifying not because it is true, but because of how far you have gone to make sure you never feel angry at all.
Think of the woman who apologizes when someone else bumps into her. She is careful never to burden anyone with anger. One evening, while chopping vegetables beside someone she loves, a thought flashes through her mind: I could hurt them. She recoils. Soon she is asking what kind of person could think such a thing. The question sticks because she has spent so long trying to be someone who would never even feel anger.
Intrusive sexual thoughts can get caught in a similar pattern. Say you learned early that desire was shameful or that parts of yourself must stay hidden. A sexual thought you never wanted then seems to expose something bad about you. You check your reaction to it, searching for a sign of what it means, and the checking keeps you close to the very thought you want to leave alone.
I think of the intrusive thought as a pressure valve. The harder you seal off a part of your own experience, the more forcefully it announces itself, in the most frightening form you can imagine. Because it horrifies you, you seal it off even harder, and the cycle tightens. It may feel as though the only way to be good is to control every thought.
It works like holding a beach ball underwater. The harder you push it down, the harder it shoves back up, and the more of your strength it takes to keep it there. That is how intrusive thoughts can take up a day: one hand is always underwater, holding something down.
This is also why, in my clinical experience, even successful ERP can leave the underlying pattern in place. The fear around one thought may ease, only for a new one to get caught later. The thought changes, but the old rule stays: there are parts of my mind I must never allow. The work I do is with that rule.
How I work with this
My approach comes from the character-analytic tradition. I do not treat an intrusive thought as a secret message waiting to be decoded. Hunting for its meaning can become another form of checking. I pay attention instead to the part of yourself that you have learned to keep under control.
You do not need to tell me the details of your worst thought if you don't want to. You might still feel driven to tell me every detail, as if holding one back would make you dishonest. We can look at that pressure without turning the session into another round of checking. I notice, for example, if you dismiss your own anger, laugh off something that hurt you, or become sure you have done something wrong before anyone says so. These moments give us a way to see the same pattern in the session, as it happens.
Say you tell me you were upset with a friend, then quickly add that you had no right to be. I ask how you reached that verdict. We stay with the moment when you gave up your own view. This is not a test you can pass by saying the right thing. It is a chance to see how fast you turn against what you feel.
The aim is to loosen the hold that old rule has on you. When you no longer need to keep a part of yourself under constant surveillance, intrusive thoughts can lose their charge. They become what they always were: noise. They are not prophecy, evidence, or a verdict on your character. They come from a mind that is allowed to think whatever it thinks.
Sessions are 60 minutes over secure video. Before your first session, we have a free 15-minute consultation to see if this feels right. There are no assignments or worksheets to complete between sessions. We pay attention to what happens as we talk.
If you have thoughts of ending your life, get help now rather than wait for a session. Call the emergency number where you live, or a crisis line. The link "Crisis resources" at the bottom of this page has lines by country.
Not sure yet? That's what the free consultation is for.
Request a free 15-min consultationFrequently asked questions
Does everyone have intrusive thoughts?
Is this OCD?
How is this different from CBT or ERP?
What does it cost?
Related reading
What Clients Say
“A few years ago I suddenly developed prolonged panic attacks but couldn't begin to understand what had caused them. Having been in therapy in the past, and being a counseling intern student, I felt I had exhausted my resources trying to figure out “What is wrong with me?” I can honestly say Aaron provides a form of counseling that is difficult to find anywhere else regarding efficacy. Not only has his approach been effective, but he also has provided me a safe space to explore aspects about myself I may not otherwise have felt able to. I cannot recommend him enough as he has helped me feel more myself than ever before.”
AB
Selected research on this approach
My work is psychodynamic and depth-oriented. These are some of the studies on the effectiveness of that kind of therapy. They describe research on the method in general, and are not claims about any individual outcome.
- Shedler, J. (2010). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy. American Psychologist, 65(2), 98-109. doi:10.1037/a0018378
- Steinert, C., Munder, T., Rabung, S., Hoyer, J., & Leichsenring, F. (2017). Psychodynamic therapy: as efficacious as other empirically supported treatments? A meta-analysis testing equivalence of outcomes. American Journal of Psychiatry, 174(10), 943-953. PMID 28541091
- Leichsenring, F., Abbass, A., Heim, N., Keefe, J. R., Kisely, S., Luyten, P., Rabung, S., & Steinert, C. (2023). The status of psychodynamic psychotherapy as an empirically supported treatment for common mental disorders: an umbrella review based on updated criteria. World Psychiatry, 22(2), 286-304. PMC10168167
Contact Aaron
You do not have to know what to say. A few sentences is enough.