It starts with a thought. Something violent, sexual, blasphemous, or just wrong. It arrives uninvited and it feels like yours. You try to push it away and it comes back louder. You try to reason with it and it multiplies. You start wondering what it means about you. Whether you are dangerous. Whether you are sick. Whether you are the kind of person who would actually do the thing you keep thinking about.
You are not. The fact that the thought horrifies you is itself the evidence. People who act on violent or harmful impulses do not typically spend their days in agony about having them. But you cannot talk yourself out of the fear, because the fear is not about logic. It is about the relationship you have developed with your own mind, and that relationship has gone wrong somewhere.
What the research actually shows
The most important finding in the entire intrusive thoughts literature is this: almost everyone has them. Studies going back to the late 1970s, starting with the work of Rachman and de Silva, have consistently found that 80 to 99 percent of the general population reports experiencing unwanted intrusive thoughts. The content is often identical to what you see in clinical OCD: thoughts about harming loved ones, sexual thoughts that feel wrong, images of catastrophe, impulses to do something terrible in public. The thoughts themselves are not what separates people who struggle from people who don't.
What separates them is what happens next. In people without clinical distress, an intrusive thought arrives, gets noticed, and passes. In people who develop problems, the thought arrives and gets caught. It gets caught because the person appraises it as meaningful. They treat the thought as evidence of something about themselves. Having the thought of pushing someone onto the train tracks becomes: maybe I am a violent person. Having an unwanted sexual image becomes: maybe I secretly want this. The appraisal creates distress. The distress creates an urge to suppress the thought. And suppression, as decades of research have shown, makes the thought come back more often and more intensely.
This is the paradox at the center of intrusive thoughts. The thing you are doing to make them go away is the thing that is keeping them here.
Why the standard advice has limits
The standard clinical approach to intrusive thoughts is Exposure and Response Prevention, usually delivered within a CBT framework. The basic idea: expose yourself to the feared thought without performing any ritual or avoidance behavior, and eventually the distress diminishes. This approach has strong evidence behind it and helps many people. If you have access to a good ERP therapist, it is worth trying.
But there is something that ERP, and CBT more broadly, tends not to ask. It treats the intrusive thought as the problem and the appraisal of the thought as the error to be corrected. What it does not typically explore is: why does this particular person, with this particular history, appraise their thoughts this way in the first place? Why does one person let a dark thought float by while another person grabs onto it and cannot let go?
The answer, in most cases, has nothing to do with OCD in any technical sense. It has to do with the person's characteristic way of relating to their own inner life. Their relationship to their own impulses, their own aggression, their own sexuality, their own vulnerability. The intrusive thought is not random. It tends to land precisely on whatever the person has the most difficulty accepting about themselves.
What is actually going on
Here is the pattern I see over and over. The person with intrusive violent thoughts is almost always someone who has enormous difficulty with their own anger. Not someone who is secretly violent. Someone who is so afraid of their own aggression that any hint of it, even in the form of a fleeting thought, triggers a full alarm response. The thought I could hurt someone is terrifying not because it is true but because this person has spent their whole life making absolutely sure they never express anger, never inconvenience anyone, never take up too much space.
The person with intrusive sexual thoughts is almost always someone with a complicated, suppressed relationship to their own desire. Not someone with deviant impulses. Someone who learned early on that certain parts of themselves were unacceptable, and who has been policing their inner world ever since.
The intrusive thought is like a pressure valve. The more tightly you seal off some part of your experience, the more violently it tries to announce itself. And because it announces itself in the most horrifying form possible, you seal it off even harder. And the cycle tightens.
This is why pure thought suppression doesn't work. And it is why even successful ERP, while it can reduce the distress around specific thoughts, sometimes doesn't touch the underlying pattern. The person stops being tormented by one particular thought and six months later a new one arrives. Because the structure that generates intrusive thoughts, the war with some unacceptable part of yourself, is still operating.
How I work with this
My approach comes from the character-analytic tradition. I don't treat intrusive thoughts as a symptom to be managed. I treat them as information about a conflict that is happening below the surface. Something in you is trying to get your attention, and the form it has taken is the very thing you find most intolerable. That is not a coincidence.
In practice, this means we pay attention to the structure underneath the thought. Not the content. You do not need to tell me the details of your worst thought if you don't want to. What interests me is the pattern: how you relate to your own impulses, your own feelings, your own aggression and desire. What you allow yourself to feel and what you have decided is off limits. Where that decision came from and whether it still makes sense.
The work is not about learning to tolerate the thoughts better, though that tends to happen. It is about loosening the structure that generates them in the first place. When you no longer need to keep a part of yourself under constant surveillance, the thoughts lose their charge. They become what they always were: noise. Not prophecy, not evidence, not a verdict on your character. Just the random firing of a mind that is allowed to think whatever it thinks.
Sessions are 60 minutes over secure video. Before your first session, we have a brief 15-minute call to see if this feels right. No homework. No worksheets. The work happens in the room.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Contact Aaron
You do not have to know what to say. A few sentences is enough.