In short Depth therapy for overthinking works with what the constant analysis is protecting you from feeling, rather than with tips to quiet the mind. Online, weekly, in English. For adults stuck in their heads and out of reach of their lives.

Say you make a list, talk it through with a friend, then look online for one more answer. A choice starts to feel clear. Then another objection arrives: What if I'm wrong? What if there's something I missed? The thinking starts again, and the decision is no closer. It can feel as though one more piece of information would finally settle it.

The usual advice is to trust your gut, set a deadline, meditate, or write down the pros and cons. That may help with an ordinary hard choice. But when overthinking has become a pattern, each new method gives you one more thing to weigh. The thinking buys time. It holds off the moment when what you want would have to count as a reason.

Overthinking has a purpose: it keeps you busy enough to avoid knowing what you actually feel. Rumination works much the same way with choices already made. My work begins with why trusting yourself came to feel so hard.

What the overthinking is actually doing

Say you start leaning toward one option. A small feeling of relief tells you which way you want to go. Then the counterarguments arrive. What about the money? What will your family think? Those concerns are real and worth taking seriously. But notice when they turn up. Each time a preference becomes clear, the overthinking pattern swings you back to the middle. The fence is restored, and you are once again weighing two choices, with no need to make either one.

The overthinking is not failing to produce a decision. It is succeeding at preventing one. Another round of reasons ends with the same answer: I still don't know. In my view, the missing piece is not more information. The pattern keeps a feeling from serving as a reason. Knowing what you want would mean trusting it, and that is the very step the overthinking is there to avoid.

Say you get a job offer in another city. On Monday, taking it looks right: better pay and a fresh start. On Tuesday, staying makes sense: your friends are here, and the new boss might be worse. Wednesday you build a spreadsheet. By Friday, you are asking someone else what they would do. Sunday night you are exactly where you started, only more tired. Somewhere that week you felt a pull one way or the other. The counterarguments exist to erase that pull.

What working together would look like

Tell me about one message you keep rewriting because no reply feels right. I'll ask what you want to say, whose reaction you fear, and what happens between having that first thought and finding reasons to doubt it.

We meet online. A 60-minute session costs €175, or £150 for clients in the UK.

The gap between should and want

The overthinking I work with has a gap at its center: what you want and what you think you should want. The should has a voice. A good person makes time for family. A sensible person keeps a secure job. A kind person doesn't disappoint anyone. Those rules come from people around you, at home or in the wider world. The want is quieter. Sometimes it appears as a feeling before you can explain it.

If you learned that wanting something is selfish, your own feelings do not seem like good enough reasons. You need a case that would convince everyone, even the person most likely to disapprove. So you gather reasons and counterreasons, looking for a choice no one could fault. Meanwhile, your own preference is left out of the evidence. Overthinking keeps going because it has ruled out the very thing that could help settle the question.

The shoulds are threats. Each carries an unspoken "or": you should be grateful, or you are selfish. You should stay, or you are disloyal. It can feel safer to keep gathering facts than to choose and face that verdict. On the fence you have not been the bad person yet. The pattern protects you from the fear of doing wrong, even when it costs you time and peace of mind.

Say your mother calls and asks to visit for two weeks over the holidays. Your stomach answers in one second: too long. Then comes the thought that a good daughter should be glad to have her. You say, "Let me check a few things," and spend four days going over flights and calendars. The dates were never the hard part. The hard part was allowing that first answer to matter.

Rumination is the same thing, facing backward

Rumination is overthinking turned toward the past. Instead of asking what you should do, you go over what you already did. Say you left a conversation feeling angry. Later, you replay every word, coming up with a calmer answer, then a kinder one, then a way you might have avoided the whole exchange. Each replay brings back the same rule: I should have handled that better. Rumination keeps the question open, as though the past could still be decided.

What the replay leaves out is how you felt at the time. Maybe you were hurt or afraid, and your response made sense to you then. That does not mean it was the best response. It means your feelings belong in the account of what happened. If that part of the story is not allowed, rumination has to keep searching for a past in which you got everything right.

How I work with this

My approach comes from the character-analytic tradition. I work with overthinking as a pattern, rather than a problem with how well you reason. The pattern may once have helped you avoid blame or keep the peace. It keeps running even when no one is telling you what to want.

In a session, you might say, I think I want to leave, but... I notice the "but." What came before the "but" was a feeling. What comes after it is the defense. We stay with what came before. Did it seem selfish to say it aloud? I do not ask you to decide on the spot. We look at how quickly a preference can be argued out of existence, right there while we are speaking.

I want your feelings to have a place in the decision. A feeling is neither the only evidence nor a command you must obey. You can weigh it alongside money, time, duty, and other people's needs. But it belongs in the discussion. The change is being able to say, "I want this, and that is a real reason," even if you choose otherwise. Careful thought still matters. It no longer has to stand in for what you feel.

We meet for 60 minutes by secure video. Before your first session, we have a free 15-minute consultation to see if this feels like the right fit for you. I do not ask you to keep thought records or fill out decision matrices. We work with the pattern as it appears between us.

The overthinking was never about the decisions. It was about the right to make them.

Frequently asked questions

Is overthinking a mental health condition?

Not formally. Chronic overthinking and rumination are features of anxiety, depression, and obsessive patterns. I work with what the pattern keeps you from feeling, rather than treating the thinking alone as the problem.

How is this different from CBT for rumination?

I focus on why rumination keeps starting again, while CBT works on interrupting it and challenging thoughts. We look at what feeling gets pushed aside when the next round of thinking begins. The question is what the thinking does for you, rather than only what it says.

I have trouble making decisions. Is that overthinking?

Usually, yes. If each choice sends you back to the same doubts, overthinking is keeping your own preference out of the decision. I work with what makes it hard to feel entitled to decide on the basis of what you want.

What does it cost?

Sessions are 60 minutes and cost €175, or £150 for clients in the UK. Before your first session, we have a free 15-minute consultation to see if this feels like the right fit for you. More at fees.

Fifteen minutes is enough to know if this fits.

Request a free 15-min consultation

Related reading

Your privacy with me. No insurance, no diagnosis codes, no health registry, no GP notification, no employer visibility. You pay directly. What you say in sessions stays confidential. I share it only if you agree. There are two exceptions. One is when the law requires it. The other is when there is an imminent risk of serious harm to you or others. More about private therapy

What Clients Say

“A few years ago I suddenly developed prolonged panic attacks but couldn't begin to understand what had caused them. Having been in therapy in the past, and being a counseling intern student, I felt I had exhausted my resources trying to figure out “What is wrong with me?” I can honestly say Aaron provides a form of counseling that is difficult to find anywhere else regarding efficacy. Not only has his approach been effective, but he also has provided me a safe space to explore aspects about myself I may not otherwise have felt able to. I cannot recommend him enough as he has helped me feel more myself than ever before.”

AB

Selected research on this approach

My work is psychodynamic and depth-oriented. These are some of the studies on the effectiveness of that kind of therapy. They describe research on the method in general, and are not claims about any individual outcome.

  • Shedler, J. (2010). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy. American Psychologist, 65(2), 98-109. doi:10.1037/a0018378
  • Steinert, C., Munder, T., Rabung, S., Hoyer, J., & Leichsenring, F. (2017). Psychodynamic therapy: as efficacious as other empirically supported treatments? A meta-analysis testing equivalence of outcomes. American Journal of Psychiatry, 174(10), 943-953. PMID 28541091
  • Leichsenring, F., Abbass, A., Heim, N., Keefe, J. R., Kisely, S., Luyten, P., Rabung, S., & Steinert, C. (2023). The status of psychodynamic psychotherapy as an empirically supported treatment for common mental disorders: an umbrella review based on updated criteria. World Psychiatry, 22(2), 286-304. PMC10168167
  • Keefe, J. R., McCarthy, K. S., Dinger, U., Zilcha-Mano, S., & Barber, J. P. (2014). A meta-analytic review of psychodynamic therapies for anxiety disorders. Clinical Psychology Review, 34(4), 309-323. PMID 24786897

Request a free 15-minute consultation

You do not have to be ready. You do not have to know what to say. A few sentences is enough.

I read and answer every message myself. You will hear back within 24 hours, usually much sooner.
So I can offer times in your time zone. I'm not able to take on clients based in the United States.