You finished the PhD. You published. You moved to another city, maybe another country, for the postdoc. You are doing good work. The next position is uncertain, and the question is getting harder to put aside: is this going to lead anywhere?
Say a friend asks where you'll live next year. Your answer depends on the next postdoc. If that has been the answer for years, even a question about where to live puts the rest of your life in the hands of another committee.
The work keeps giving you a reason to wait. There is another grant, another contract, another application. Each one leaves open the hope that you will finally have a stable position and be able to make plans. You have a reason to go on, but no clear moment to reckon with what the waiting has taken from you. A future that hasn't been ruled out is hard to mourn.
Your twenties went to the PhD. Your early thirties went to the postdoc. Friends outside academia have careers, mortgages, stability. You have a contract that expires in eighteen months and a CV that impresses people who don't know what a postdoc earns.
A survey of 676 postdocs ran in the Netherlands. About four in ten reported serious mental health problems. Two of the stresses it named were thin career odds and a lack of institutional support.
The sunk cost trap
The most dangerous thought in the postdoc experience is: I have come too far to stop now. It keeps you in a position that is harming you because leaving would mean facing the possibility that years of sacrifice did not lead where they were supposed to. It feels as if that admission would undo the meaning of the whole effort.
This is an emotional calculation. If you stay in a toxic lab, on a poverty salary, with no career prospects, you are not making a career decision. You are avoiding a feeling. The feeling is grief. The future you worked toward may not exist. Yet there is often no event that marks the loss. A contract is extended, another fellowship opens, or a committee has yet to decide. Hope stays technically alive, and the grief stays unfelt because there is no clear loss to name. To grieve while a chance remains feels like giving up that chance yourself.
The strategies that got you through graduate school (persistence, self-discipline, deferred gratification) are exactly the strategies that prevent you from facing the grief, because those strategies say: if you just keep going, it will work out.
The next fellowship application looks reasonable. It has a clear deadline, something you know how to meet. It also pushes the question of an ending back another year. Each application keeps the larger question out of reach.
It may work out. It also may not. And the inability to sit with that uncertainty, to hold both possibilities without collapsing into either one, is what makes the postdoc experience so psychologically punishing.
Not sure yet? That's what the free consultation is for.
Request a free 15-min consultationThe numbness
It is easy to miss. This is not depression in the clinical sense, though it can become that. It is what happens when suppressing your needs and feelings becomes automatic. For example, you push down exhaustion until the paper is done and anger until the contract ends. There is always another task. You do not feel burned out, because you have lost the ability to register your own exhaustion. The warning signals are firing, but you have spent a decade training yourself to override them.
The identity question
If you went from college at eighteen to graduate school and then to a postdoc, academia has framed nearly all of your adult life. By your mid-thirties, it has shaped where you live and whom you know. Your friendships are academic. Your sense of competence is academic. Your answer to "what do you do?" is academic.
When the career starts to feel precarious, what is actually at stake is more than a job. It is you. The person you have been building since you were a teenager. The question "should I leave academia?" is about whether you can survive as a person without the framework that has organized your life since you were old enough to have one.
Try this: at a party, someone asks what you do, and you imagine answering without the word "research" or the name of your field. Notice what happens in your chest. That flicker of blankness, or panic, is the size of the question you are actually facing. It was never really about the job market.
How I work with this
I do not help you optimize your career or coach you on whether to stay or leave. I help you see the patterns keeping you stuck: the ways you have organized yourself around external validation, deferred living, and the suppression of your feelings, including grief, clearly enough that they stop running automatically.
Suppose I ask what you'd mourn if the answer were no today. You go quiet, then mention another fellowship. I tell you, "I noticed you went straight to the next application when I asked what you would lose."
I come from the character-analytic tradition. I have two master's degrees, one in counseling from La Salle and one in sociology from UC Berkeley. I understand the academic world because I was in it.
Sessions are 60 minutes over secure video. We begin with a free 15-minute consultation to see if we're a good fit. What privacy means here.
Frequently asked questions
I am on a visa tied to my position. Will this affect my status?
Can I afford this on a postdoc salary?
I am not sure whether I need therapy or just a career change.
Related reading
What Clients Say
“I came in thinking I knew what my issues were. I'd been over them a hundred times. But those were just the things I could already see. Aaron helped me notice what I couldn't, and that's where everything actually started to change.”
MK
Request a free 15-minute consultation
You do not have to be ready. You do not have to know what to say. A few sentences is enough.