Suppose you get promoted. Your manager says you've earned it, and everyone is pleased. You thank them, then spend the evening wondering when they'll discover they chose the wrong person. The work that got you there seems irrelevant. The new role gives them more reasons to notice your supposed shortcomings. With impostor syndrome, success raises the stakes of being found out.
Perhaps you've listed qualifications, saved kind emails, or tried to accept a compliment. The evidence is there, and relief lasts a moment. Then the next task arrives. Was the last success luck? Did people overestimate you? Have you reached the point where you won't get away with it? The proof never settles the question.
What impostor syndrome actually is
The usual account calls impostor syndrome a mistaken belief about your abilities. You're competent, but you think you're a fraud. Correct the belief with enough evidence and the feeling should disappear. Yet people who have degrees, strong reviews, and years of good work still expect to be exposed. The evidence is already there. It has no place to land.
Impostor syndrome is a refusal to accept yourself as you are. The story offers two versions of you: secretly extraordinary, with a reputation that must never slip, or secretly inadequate, waiting for discovery. Both versions keep ordinary competence out of the picture. You are competent. Solidly, unspectacularly competent. Good at some things, mediocre at others, occasionally brilliant, sometimes wrong. Your limits do not make you a fraud.
When your early worth was tied to being exceptional, ordinariness feels like annihilation. Being "the smart one" or "the talented one" came to stand for being worthy of love. The old bargain survives even when no one is asking for proof. The "temporarily embarrassed genius" prefers the anxious question "Am I a fraud?" to the plain answer I am good at this. Good, with limits. Good is enough.
For example, a talk goes fine. People follow it, ask useful questions, and thank you. If you're caught in this pattern, "fine" never becomes the account you keep. By evening it has turned into a hidden disaster, or a warning that the next talk must be flawless. The event itself was ordinary. The story has to make it extraordinary, one way or the other.
Not sure yet? That's what the free consultation is for.
Request a free 15-min consultationWhere it comes from
Impostor syndrome often begins where a child learns that love must be earned. Being called clever or gifted is pleasant, but if praise arrives mainly for achievement, the lesson is clear: being valued depends on performing. The child learns to present the accomplished self and keep the struggling one out of sight. Later, with each ordinary piece of work, you are proving, once again, that you deserve to exist.
Sometimes the lesson came as "A 98? What happened to the other two points?" Sometimes it was "You're so smart, you're going to do great things," repeated with pride and affection. You heard a promise about who you were supposed to become. A mistake then threatens more than a grade. It threatens the place you were praised for holding.
The perfectionism is not incidental. A 2025 review by Hill and Gotwals pooled 25 studies with more than 12,000 people. It found a large link between impostor feelings and perfectionistic concerns. The link with striving for excellence was small. The overlap seemed to come mainly from a need to appear perfect to others. The person with impostor syndrome is not primarily anxious about their work. They are anxious about what their work reveals about who they are.
This is why a promotion turns into a new demand. Imagine finishing a hard project and hearing that people trust you with more responsibility. Their confidence feels like another task: make sure they never regret believing in you. The goalpost moves as soon as you reach it. Contentment lasts about as long as a held breath. Then the next expectation takes over, and impostor syndrome asks what you'll have to prove tomorrow.
Why reassurance doesn't work
If a boss says your work is excellent, the words reach your ears, but the feeling of being a fraud stays. Repeating the praise won't fix that. Reassurance fails because you cannot receive it as a statement about the person who actually did the work. Accepting it would mean taking in a self you learned to judge as inadequate long before this job began.
An evidence log meets the same resistance. Suppose you save the messages from pleased clients, the reviews, the results. Look at any entry and there's a reason to set it aside. That project was easy. That colleague was being kind. The timing was lucky. You can keep adding proof without ever letting it count. The list grows while the fear stays where it was.
This is not a thinking error. It is a character structure. It shapes what you see when someone praises you and how you judge your own work afterward. It has organized your relationship to achievement and to your own worth for years. More evidence passes through the same pattern and comes out as another demand to perform.
When the environment is part of the problem
Impostor feelings also arise in settings that question people's right to belong. If you're the only person who looks like you in a meeting, a woman in a field built for men, the first in your family to enter a profession, an immigrant, or a person of color in a largely white institution, the signals you receive matter. A remark, a hiring decision, or an assumption about your qualifications may tell you that others see you as an outsider. Those experiences are real, and impostor syndrome does not explain them away.
Research confirms the pattern. Cokley et al. (2017, 2024) found that impostor feelings among racial and ethnic minorities are often a proximal consequence of racism-related stress: the more discrimination a person reports, the stronger the impostor feelings. McGee (2020) found that Black doctoral students in STEM understood their experience as both impostorism and racism, and that university administrators who diagnose them with impostor syndrome are sometimes providing a cover for institutional problems.
There is a difference between recognizing an unfair environment and accepting its opinion of you. Suppose colleagues assume someone else did the important part of your work. You may be reading their attitude correctly. You may also lack the cultural advantages that others have had for years, or face assumptions about why you were hired. The barriers are real, and their judgment of your worth remains false. Every person in that room has gaps in knowledge and experience, including those who seem fully at home there. Those gaps do not settle who belongs.
If an institution treats you as though you have to earn entry again every morning, that deserves to be named. I do not ask you to deny it or perform gratitude for being "included." The work is to separate what people actually do from the authority you've given their view of you. You need your own assessment of your abilities and limits, even when the room refuses to recognize it. A hostile setting does not get to tell you who you are.
How I work with this
My approach comes from the character-analytic tradition. I understand impostor syndrome as a way of relating to yourself that formed for good reasons early in life. It now runs automatically, turning work into a repeated test of worth. We watch it happen in session.
I do not set out to build your confidence. I ask why you cannot let it in. Whose approval depended on your being exceptional? What happened when you needed help? What would it feel like to sit with the satisfaction of something accomplished without scanning for the next threat? We watch how quickly you explain away praise or look for another standard.
It appears between us too. Suppose you describe finishing a hard project, then add that it was nothing special. I ask why you said that. You explain that you don't want to sound conceited. We look at what felt risky about my hearing your success. Even this conversation has become another place to prove yourself. I point that out while it is happening. I am your therapist, and I am not grading you.
You can be confused, uncertain, or ordinary with me, and our relationship continues. Being valued without performing is where change happens.
Each session is 60 minutes, over secure video. Before the first session, we use a free 15-minute consultation to see if working together feels right. I don't assign homework or ask for evidence logs. We look at what happens in our conversations.
The aim is to stop needing another accomplishment to justify the place you already occupy.
Frequently asked questions
Isn't impostor syndrome just low self-esteem?
How is this different from coaching?
I am actually good at my job. Why do I still feel this way?
What if my impostor feelings are partly about being the only one like me in the room?
What does it cost?
Fifteen minutes is enough to know if this fits.
Request a free 15-min consultationRelated reading
What Clients Say
“I came in thinking I knew what my issues were. I'd been over them a hundred times. But those were just the things I could already see. Aaron helped me notice what I couldn't, and that's where everything actually started to change.”
MK
Selected research on this approach
My work is psychodynamic and depth-oriented. These are some of the studies on the effectiveness of that kind of therapy. They describe research on the method in general, and are not claims about any individual outcome.
- Shedler, J. (2010). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy. American Psychologist, 65(2), 98-109. doi:10.1037/a0018378
- Steinert, C., Munder, T., Rabung, S., Hoyer, J., & Leichsenring, F. (2017). Psychodynamic therapy: as efficacious as other empirically supported treatments? A meta-analysis testing equivalence of outcomes. American Journal of Psychiatry, 174(10), 943-953. PMID 28541091
- Leichsenring, F., Abbass, A., Heim, N., Keefe, J. R., Kisely, S., Luyten, P., Rabung, S., & Steinert, C. (2023). The status of psychodynamic psychotherapy as an empirically supported treatment for common mental disorders: an umbrella review based on updated criteria. World Psychiatry, 22(2), 286-304. PMC10168167
Request a free 15-minute consultation
You do not have to be ready. You do not have to know what to say. A few sentences is enough.